Supreme Court Questions Recruitment of Civic Volunteers, Orders Restrictions on Deployments in Sensitive Areas

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, October 15, 2024, Delhi: In a significant development, the Supreme Court of India has issued a major order regarding the recruitment and deployment of civic volunteers across the country. During a hearing today, Chief Justice DY Chandrachud raised crucial questions about how civic volunteers are recruited, their legal framework, and their placement in sensitive institutions like hospitals and schools.

This scrutiny comes in the wake of the controversial RG Kar case, where the role of a civic volunteer has been under the scanner. The main accused in the case, as identified by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) in a newly submitted charge sheet, is a civic volunteer, sparking widespread concern. Many, including doctors and forensic experts, have expressed doubts about whether the accused acted alone, with large sections of the public echoing these suspicions. Despite these doubts, the CBI has continued to hold the civic volunteer as the prime suspect, facing mounting pressure from various quarters.

The Supreme Court’s curiosity regarding the civic volunteer system became evident during today’s hearing, as the Chief Justice questioned the state government on the processes involved in their recruitment. The court ordered the state to file an affidavit detailing several aspects of the civic volunteer system, including:

Recruitment process: How are civic volunteers recruited, and what legal framework governs their hiring?

Authority and oversight: Who oversees the recruitment process, and how are civic volunteers selected and trained?

Verification and deployment: What are the procedures for background verification of civic volunteers, and where are they being deployed?

Chief Justice Chandrachud emphasized the need for transparency and accountability, particularly in light of the involvement of civic volunteers in sensitive locations. In a bold move, the Supreme Court further directed that civic volunteers should no longer be appointed in critical areas such as hospitals and schools, given the potential risks associated with their deployment.

The court's orders mark a crucial turning point in the ongoing debate surrounding civic volunteers and their growing presence in the state's administrative and security infrastructure. Since their introduction, the role of civic volunteers has expanded significantly, but their accountability, training, and legal standing have remained contentious issues. The RG Kar case, which has drawn national attention due to the brutal rape and murder of a doctor, has placed the spotlight on this loosely regulated system.

The appointment of civic volunteers in government-backed projects like the Ratra Sathi project has also raised alarms. Senior lawyer Karuna Nandi expressed concern in court today about the expanding scope of civic volunteers under this program, claiming that recruitment levels have doubled without adequate oversight. This project, intended to support nighttime patrols and security, now faces criticism for its unchecked recruitment of volunteers, many of whom are believed to lack sufficient training or background checks.

In light of these revelations, today’s Supreme Court order has placed significant pressure on the state government to overhaul the civic volunteer system. The court's insistence on accountability reflects rising concerns about the role of these volunteers in maintaining public safety, particularly when deployed in environments requiring higher levels of scrutiny and professionalism.

As the state government prepares to respond to the court’s orders, there is growing anticipation over what reforms might follow. For now, the Supreme Court’s directives have effectively halted the appointment of civic volunteers in hospitals and schools, setting a precedent for stricter regulation of their recruitment and deployment in the future. The next few weeks will likely see the state submit its affidavit, and the outcome of these proceedings could reshape the future of the civic volunteer system in India.