Women Face Confusion Over ID Proof Requirements for Free Bus Travel Scheme in West Bengal
A passenger travelling from Kurseong to Siliguri on November 12 took to social media after a conductor allegedly insisted on an original physical Aadhaar card or another original identity document, refusing to accept a photograph of the document on her phone. She said the conductor showed her a notice stating that photocopies would not be accepted and original documents were mandatory.
After checking the government’s guidelines during the journey, the passenger said she could find no such requirement. “Who is right, and who is accountable?” she asked, urging the Transport department to publish the applicable instructions and ensure uniformity across buses and depots.
The Transport department’s May 21 notification lists Aadhaar, voter ID, driving licence, PAN card, passport and other government-issued photo identity documents for identifying beneficiaries until QR code-based smart cards are issued. However, it does not explicitly state whether digital versions displayed on mobile phones must be accepted.
Transport minister Arjun Singh had earlier advised women to carry colour photocopies of their Aadhaar cards. On September 25, however, he said Aadhaar could also be shown on a mobile phone, provided the photograph matched the passenger.
NBSTC Managing Director Ashwini Kumar Roy said: “The government’s directive is very positive. We have told everyone that there is no need to be so rigid. Whether a woman shows a hard copy or a soft copy, she should not be denied the facility.”
An SBSTC official also said properly displayed digital identity documents could be accepted.
“If someone can show the digital document properly, there should be no problem. Documents downloaded from the Aadhaar website or available through DigiLocker are also applicable. No organisation can go beyond what is permitted under the IT Act,” the official said.
A WBTC conductor, speaking on condition of anonymity, cited practical difficulties in accepting digital documents on crowded, moving buses. He referred to an incident in which a woman’s iPhone 16 reportedly slipped from her hand while she was showing her Aadhaar card and was damaged. The conductor concerned was allegedly kept off duty for two months, he said.
Another passenger, Aparna Paul, said a WBTC AC bus conductor accepted her Aadhaar displayed through the mAadhaar App but advised her to carry a photocopy on her next journey.
The discrepancy has raised questions over the scheme’s implementation, particularly as the central government promotes Digital India. Conflicting interpretations have left passengers and conductors in a difficult position, underlining the need for a clear, written directive from the Transport department.
0 Response to "Women Face Confusion Over ID Proof Requirements for Free Bus Travel Scheme in West Bengal"
Post a Comment
Disclaimer Note:
The views expressed in the articles published here are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy, position, or perspective of Kalimpong News or KalimNews. Kalimpong News and KalimNews disclaim all liability for the published or posted articles, news, and information and assume no responsibility for the accuracy or validity of the content.
Kalimpong News is a non-profit online news platform managed by KalimNews and operated under the Kalimpong Press Club.
Comment Policy:
We encourage respectful and constructive discussions. Please ensure decency while commenting and register with your email ID to participate.
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.