-->
Journalism Is More Than a Press Card: Understanding Press Freedom and the Right to Record

Journalism Is More Than a Press Card: Understanding Press Freedom and the Right to Record


Geetartha Pathak, November 19, 2026, New Delhi: The affidavit filed by the Delhi Police before the Supreme Court in connection with allegations of harassment and detention of journalists during the October protests at Jantar Mantar has raised an important question about the identity, responsibilities and rights of journalists in the rapidly changing digital media landscape. While the police have attempted to distinguish professional journalists from social media influencers and YouTube reel-makers, their argument also exposes a more fundamental problem: the growing tendency of law enforcement agencies to treat the presence of cameras and microphones at protest sites with suspicion.

The controversy originated from complaints by several journalists and media organisations, including the Network of Women in Media, Free Speech Collective, Delhi Union of Journalists and Kerala Union of Working Journalists, alleging that journalists covering the protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar were harassed, manhandled and detained by Delhi Police personnel. The Supreme Court had intervened on October 11, making it clear that journalists, lawyers and other professionals should not be hindered in discharging their professional duties.

In its affidavit, filed by Joint Commissioner of Police Surender Kumar, Delhi Police has denied any deliberate or coordinated attempt to obstruct journalists. It has argued that professional journalists constitute a distinct category from individuals carrying cameras and microphones to create content for social media platforms, including for commercial exploitation. The police have also cited instances in which certain individuals allegedly identified themselves as journalists while participating in protests and raising slogans.

There is an element of justification in the police argument that professional journalism cannot be equated with every form of social media content creation. However, the manner in which this distinction has been invoked raises serious concerns, particularly when the affidavit appears to use the presence of content creators as an explanation for the difficulties faced by police personnel in identifying journalists.

The distinction between journalism and content creation

It is important to recognise that journalism is not simply the act of recording an event, uploading a video or attracting viewers through social media. Journalism is a profession involving the collection, verification and dissemination of information in the public interest. Accuracy, fairness, independence, accountability and adherence to established journalistic ethics distinguish responsible journalism from entertainment-oriented content creation and unverified social media commentary.

A person who regularly produces entertainment reels, promotional videos or sensational content cannot automatically claim to be a professional journalist merely because he or she carries a microphone or camera. Nor should anyone be permitted to misuse a fabricated press identity card to gain access to restricted areas or claim privileges reserved for journalists performing legitimate professional duties. Such fraudulent claims must be investigated and dealt with under the law.

However, the distinction must not be drawn merely on the basis of the platform used, the possession of a camera, the absence of formal accreditation or the possibility of earning revenue from content. Journalism today is no longer confined to newspapers, television channels and conventional news agencies. Digital news portals, independent online publications, freelance journalists and individual reporters have become integral parts of the media ecosystem.

A journalist working for a recognised digital news organisation is no less a journalist than one employed by a print newspaper or television channel. Similarly, an independent journalist reporting through a digital platform can perform legitimate journalistic functions even without a conventional employer-issued identity card.

Commercial considerations also cannot be the decisive test. Newspapers and television channels themselves operate commercially, generate revenue through advertisements and monetise their digital content. Therefore, earning money from online content cannot, by itself, disqualify someone from being a journalist. The real distinction lies in the nature, purpose and standards of the work.

Freedom to record belongs to every citizen

More importantly, the question of who qualifies as a journalist must be separated from the constitutional right to record and disseminate information.

Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution guarantees every citizen freedom of speech and expression. The right to photograph, record videos and disseminate information is an important dimension of this freedom. A citizen does not have to become a professional journalist, obtain PIB accreditation or secure a press card from a media organisation before exercising this constitutional right.

Social media users, independent videographers, documentary filmmakers, researchers and ordinary citizens have the right to photograph and record public events, subject to reasonable restrictions imposed by law. They may document a protest, record police action, capture an incident of public importance or share their observations with others. Whether such activity amounts to professional journalism is a separate question.

The police cannot make a citizen’s right to record an event conditional upon recognition as a journalist. Equally, the absence of journalistic status cannot become a ground for arbitrary detention, intimidation, confiscation of equipment or interference with lawful recording.

The Constitution does not create one category of citizens entitled to record public events and another category prohibited from doing so. Reasonable restrictions may be imposed in the interests of public order and other constitutionally recognised grounds, but such restrictions must be lawful, necessary and proportionate.

The contradictions in the police affidavit

There are certain contradictions in the Delhi Police’s submissions that deserve closer scrutiny.

On the one hand, the police have sought to establish that reel-makers and social media influencers cannot automatically claim the protections extended to journalists. On the other, the affidavit reportedly acknowledges that independent journalists, freelancers and citizens reporting through YouTube and other digital platforms enjoy constitutional freedoms to gather and publish news, irrespective of PIB accreditation or employment with a recognised media organisation.

This acknowledgement is significant. It demonstrates that the police themselves recognise that journalism and newsgathering cannot be confined to conventional media institutions.

The more important question, therefore, is not whether someone carries a press card issued by a recognised organisation, but whether that person is engaged in legitimate newsgathering and whether the police action against that person is legally justified.

The affidavit also claims that journalists were released immediately whenever their identities were verified. But this admission raises another uncomfortable question: why were journalists detained or apprehended in the first place, particularly when several of them reportedly displayed valid press identity cards?

If journalists were released after verification, does that not indicate that the initial identification and verification mechanism was inadequate? More importantly, how many journalists were detained, for how long, and what accountability has been fixed for the officers responsible?

The fact that newspapers, television channels and digital platforms subsequently published reports and videos of the protests does not, by itself, disprove allegations of harassment of individual journalists. Widespread media coverage and obstruction of particular reporters can coexist. The availability of CCTV footage and police videography should help establish what actually happened, rather than merely serve as a defence of the police version.

The allegations of physical harassment and misconduct, including those raised by women journalists, also require independent and credible examination. Such complaints cannot be disposed of simply by invoking crowd-control difficulties.

Who is a journalist and who can issue a press identity card?

India needs a transparent and inclusive mechanism for identifying working journalists without creating a system in which the government becomes the final authority on who can practise journalism.

Government accreditation, including accreditation issued by the Press Information Bureau, is one recognised form of identification. However, accreditation is not a licence to practise journalism, nor does the absence of government accreditation make someone ineligible to be a journalist.

Registered newspapers, recognised television news organisations and legitimate digital news publishers issue identity cards to their journalists and media personnel. Such credentials should be accepted for reasonable identification and facilitation by law enforcement agencies, subject to verification where necessary. Freelancers and independent journalists, who may not have a permanent employer, should also have an appropriate means of establishing their professional credentials.

The registration of a newspaper with the Registrar of Newspapers for India, now succeeded by the Press Registrar General of India, is an important institutional credential. Similarly, registration and compliance by digital news publishers under applicable legal provisions may help establish the identity of a media organisation. However, registration of an organisation and recognition of an individual as a working journalist are not identical legal questions. No single press card should be treated as the exclusive passport to the profession.

A media organisation issuing a press card must also assume responsibility for the authenticity of its credentials. Fake media organisations and fraudulent press cards should be identified and prosecuted in accordance with law.

The way forward

The present controversy provides an opportunity to develop a clear and balanced framework for journalists covering protests, demonstrations, public gatherings and other sensitive events.

First, Delhi Police and other law enforcement agencies should formulate standard operating procedures for dealing with journalists at protest sites. These should clearly distinguish between lawful newsgathering and participation in unlawful activities. A journalist should not be treated as a protester merely because he or she is recording events from close quarters.

Second, a practical verification mechanism should be established. PIB accreditation, identity cards issued by registered newspapers, established television news channels and genuine digital news organisations should be recognised. Freelancers and independent journalists should be allowed alternative forms of verification through their published work, professional references and other credible credentials. Verification must be prompt and should never become an excuse for prolonged detention.

Third, police personnel deployed for crowd control must receive regular training on press freedom, constitutional rights and the special responsibilities of journalists covering public events. Clear identification arrangements, designated media access areas where necessary and a nodal officer for media coordination can prevent avoidable confrontations. Such arrangements must not become a means of restricting independent coverage or creating media enclosures that prevent journalists from witnessing events.

Fourth, any journalist detained, assaulted or obstructed while performing professional duties must have access to an effective complaint and redressal mechanism. CCTV footage, body-camera recordings and other relevant evidence should be preserved whenever allegations of misconduct arise. Accountability must extend to individual officers as well as the institutional chain of command.

Fifth, the government should encourage media organisations and journalist bodies to evolve a voluntary, transparent system of professional identification and ethical accountability. Such a mechanism must be independent of political and administrative control. It should not become a licensing system that allows the government to decide who is entitled to question it.

Finally, the misuse of press identity cards by fraudulent content creators must be addressed through verification and legal action. But any attempt to regulate false claims must not result in the regulation of legitimate independent journalism or citizen reporting. The government must also resist the temptation to impose a narrow definition of journalism that excludes emerging digital media practices.

Protect journalism without restricting the freedom to record

The Delhi Police affidavit has brought into focus a genuine challenge confronting the media industry in the digital age. The distinction between professional journalism and entertainment-oriented content creation is necessary to preserve the credibility and professional standards of journalism. But this distinction must never be used to dilute the fundamental rights of citizens or to shield police excesses.

A person making entertainment reels cannot automatically claim to be a professional journalist. Equally, a police officer cannot assume that everyone carrying a camera at a protest is a troublemaker or a fake journalist.

The Supreme Court must examine the allegations of police misconduct independently of the larger debate over the definition of journalism. It should also lay down clear guidelines to ensure that journalists are not obstructed, harassed or detained while performing their professional duties and that citizens are not deprived of their constitutional right to record and disseminate information.

Democracy requires both responsible journalism and an informed citizenry. The freedom to question authority, document public events and expose wrongdoing cannot be made dependent on a government-issued certificate or a police officer’s subjective assessment of who is a journalist.

The ultimate test of a democracy is not how comfortably the authorities deal with favourable media coverage, but how willingly they allow journalists and citizens to record, question and scrutinise the exercise of state power.

0 Response to "Journalism Is More Than a Press Card: Understanding Press Freedom and the Right to Record"

Post a Comment

Disclaimer Note:
The views expressed in the articles published here are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy, position, or perspective of Kalimpong News or KalimNews. Kalimpong News and KalimNews disclaim all liability for the published or posted articles, news, and information and assume no responsibility for the accuracy or validity of the content.
Kalimpong News is a non-profit online news platform managed by KalimNews and operated under the Kalimpong Press Club.

Comment Policy:
We encourage respectful and constructive discussions. Please ensure decency while commenting and register with your email ID to participate.

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.