
Helplessness due to inevitable compulsion can't be considered as consent: Kerala HC
Don't Miss
Justice R Narayana Pisharadi says merely because the victim was in love with the accused, it cannot be presumed she had agreed to sexual intercourse
TT Bureau, PTI | Kochi | 20.11.21: Helplessness in the face of inevitable compulsion cannot be considered as consent, Kerala High Court has said while considering an appeal filed by a rape convict.
Justice R Narayana Pisharadi, in his order said merely because the victim was in love with the accused, it cannot be presumed that she had given consent for sexual intercourse. Court said there is a gulf of difference between consent and submission and every consent involves a submission but the converse does not follow.
"Helplessness in the face of inevitable compulsion cannot be considered to be consent as understood in law. Exercise of intelligence based on the knowledge of the significance and the moral effect of the act is required for consent. Merely for the reason that the victim was in love with the accused, it cannot be presumed that she had given consent for sexual intercourse," the court said in its order dated October 31.
The court was hearing an appeal by 26-year-old Syam Sivan, against his conviction and subsequent sentencing by trial court under various sections of the Indian Penal Code including section 376, which deals with rape.
The accused had in 2013 taken a girl, with whom he had a relation, to Mysore and had sexual intercourse with her without her consent, the court noted in its judgement. It also noted that the accused sold all her gold ornaments and then took her to Goa where he raped her again.
"Her evidence shows that he made a threat that if she did not go with him, he would commit suicide in front of her house," the court noted.
The court said even if it is assumed that, on subsequent occasions, she did not resist the act of the accused, it cannot be found that it was with her consent that the accused had sexual intercourse with her. "It can only be found that it was a passive submission made by the victim girl under unavoidable circumstances as she had no other option," the court said in the judgement.
The court, however, set aside the conviction under the POCSO act as the age of the victim was not proved. Meanwhile, it said the act of the accused clearly constitutes the offences punishable under Section 366 and 376 of the IPC (Abduction and rape).
(https://www.telegraphindia.com/india/helplessness-due-to-inevitable-compulsion-cant-be-considered-as-consent-kerala-hc/cid/1839808)
0 Response to " Helplessness due to inevitable compulsion can't be considered as consent: Kerala HC"
Post a Comment
Disclaimer Note:
The views expressed in the articles published here are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy, position, or perspective of Kalimpong News or KalimNews. Kalimpong News and KalimNews disclaim all liability for the published or posted articles, news, and information and assume no responsibility for the accuracy or validity of the content.
Kalimpong News is a non-profit online news platform managed by KalimNews and operated under the Kalimpong Press Club.
Comment Policy:
We encourage respectful and constructive discussions. Please ensure decency while commenting and register with your email ID to participate.
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.